brooklyn nine nine literally hitting homophobia in the face
I can never decide how I feel about this scene. On the one hand, it’s showing homophobia as totally unacceptable, worth punching someone over. That’s good! And it’s the friend of the gay man, so it’s showing that you should stand up for gay people even if you aren’t, which is also good.
But do you think any of the people who wrote or acted this have ever done this in their real lives? Anything even close?
I’m tired of straight people fantasizing aggressively about what they WOULD do and then never doing anything. It’s like that bit from Louis CK about how he sees servicemembers in uniform on planes and fantasizes about giving up his first class seat, and feels good about it without actually giving up his seat for them.
Don’t pretend to be a better ally than you are just because you’ve daydreamed about a power fantasy where you get to punch someone and feel justified.
In real life, I remember one–exactly one–time where a straight friend stood up for me when I was getting bullied by homophobes. She walked me from one class to the next because I’d been chased down those stairs the previous day by older boys shouting at me that I was a lesbian. One friend, one time, out of how many incidents? How many times in the five years between thirteen and eighteen before I got the hell out of that town?
And straight people want to pat themselves on the back? Do something worth self-congratulating, at least.
I liked this scene because it’s the climax of an episode in which Jake (dude doing the hitting) got to meet a guy he’d always admired for his work (dude being punched for being a homophobe) and hang out with him. And like Jake spends the early part of the episode going off about how cool this guy is and how important the work he’s done is and how this guy is the real deal and getting to hang out with this guy is basically a dream come true for Jake.
And then as he’s spending time with him, Jake starts to realize that this guy’s stuck in a way of doing things that’s about 30 years out of date, and that the way people did things 30 years ago is actually, in a lot of ways, really, really shitty. And he has a few ‘yikes’ moments, but basically he just kind of chalks it up to history, because this isn’t how cops and journalists do things now, so it’s not great, but not worth throwing down over. Like, he tries verbally getting the guy to knock it off, but nothing’s taking.
But then this happens, and it’s something that Captain Holt has been very up front about still being a huge issue in the police force, and it’s just the final nooooooooooope moment for Jake.
So the take-away message is less about punching homophobes and more about not turning a blind eye to somebody’s rancid behavior or attitudes or giving them a pass just because you respect their work or used to think they were super-cool or think of them as an authority on something.
Also, maybe the way we get more people doing the right thing in real life is by showing them what it looks like in popular media.





